Category Archives: Volunteering

Misaotra Feedback Madagascar/Ny Tanintsika and Mandra Pihaona

After six amazing months in Madagascar, our time with Ny Tanintsika came to an end in March 2015. We were sad to leave this beautiful country and people. This island, named by some as the eighth continent, is so rich in culture and energy; despite being incredibly financially poor and politically unstable; the people really make the most of what they have with a strong sense of community. We made many good friends and learned so much from our experiences. Hopefully we contributed to the organisation at least partly as much as we gained. We really were so impressed that the staff manage to make so much progress with such little funding or government support. Their tireless effort was incredibly inspiring.

We had a great farewell, the staff organised delicious snacks and music. We received a lovely hat and a locally made bright orange handbag with photos inside of our time at Ny Tanintsika. We also went to karaoke and danced with the staff at a local nightclub; this was a lot of fun. We wish you all the very best Ny Tanintsika, but for now we can only say Misaotra betsaka (many thanks) for all your lessons and support and Mandra Piona (see you later). We are thankful to Eugenie for guiding us, providing feedback and spending time showing us projects in Ambositra. Thank you to Sam for her guidance, support and patience with our many questions, you are an inspiration! We would also like to send heartfelt thanks to all the staff. Thank you for your help, guidance, and Malagasy lessons. Without your support and assistance we would not have been able to contribute as we had hoped. And of course, a huge thank you to Jamie for saying yes to us in the first place! There are so many other people we are eternally grateful to, so thank you everyone at Ny Tanintsika, we really do hope to return to this colourful, energetic country in the not too distant future.

If you want know more about this NGO, please visit our page on Feedback Madagascar / Ny Tanintsika or www.feedback.org.

Ibity Massif – Priority area for Conservation

While working at Ny Tanintsika we were fortunate to be invited on a workshop to Ibity with Missouri Botanical Garden (MBG) and Kew Madagascar (KMCC). Ibity is a small community in the central highlands of Madagascar located roughly 20km south from Antsirabe. The workshop was to identify critical ecosystem characteristics and other factors for consideration in developing a management plan for the area. This included fire regime, Tapia woodland restoration and the enhancement of existing gallery forests. Essential to a successful day we required an injection of caffeine. We shared morning coffees at a local bakery over introductions and a general discussion about MGB’s desired outcomes from the session. The charismatic Chris Birkinshaw is the project lead for MBG in Madagascar and led the discussions. He had invited local Kew environmental and restoration specialists, members from the worldwide MBG team and Stuart Cable, Kew Research leader for Madagascar.

The Ibity massif is a 6000ha quartz mountain that has been flagged as a priority area for conservation due to the large number of locally endemic plant species found there. The area contains diverse grasslands and regular rocky outcrops that lead to drainage gullies covered by some taller trees and shrubs known as gallery forests. On bands across the hillsides are small pockets of remnant Tapia woodland. Holcim (one of Madagascar’s largest cement producers) has a factory adjacent to the proposed conservation area. The company, after lobbying, has agreed to support the project and help the local community with funding to protect this unique landscape.

Our first stop at the Ibity project site was a remnant pocket of Tapia woodland. Tapia is important to the local communities as it provides edible fruit and silk cocoons. The cocoons are produced by a moth that feeds on Tapia leaves and is endemic to the highlands of Madagascar. Tapia woodland tends to occupy areas of shallow soils with rocky outcrops. This has also helped to protect the woodlands from deforestation for agricultural land as it typically grows around rocks on impoverished lands.

The field trip and workshop showed there is good understanding in the significance of numerous ecosystems/biomes in Madagascar however limited in detail to understand why some systems are failing. Madagascar has many varied environments which differ in their responses and adaptations to human interference.  More scientific investigation and experimentation is urgently required to develop detailed management plans for numerous areas of environmental significance.

Madagascar has a fast growing population that is largely impoverished and has dramatically changed the landscape at an alarmingly rate. More collaboration is required between organisations and departments with similar aims and objectives. Due to limited funding and participation, organizations needs to actively share information to avoid wasting resources on duplication. The trip to Ibity was rewarding and our sharing ideas and information will hopefully lead to better outcomes for the conservation of the Ibity massif and its stunning landscapes.

Land Tenure in Madagascar

Land in Madagascar is usually obtained through inheritance, gift, or clearing fallow land. Ownership of agricultural land is a significant determinant of welfare. 77 percent of the rural population is below the national poverty line, and those without land are the poorest. Only about 7% of agricultural land is registered.

The majority of landholders in Madagascar assert rights to land under customary law. Land is perceived as the land of the ancestors (tanindrazana). Although land may become individualized, many believe that it must be titled or recorded in some fashion before an individual can claim perpetual ownership rights to the plot. However, many villagers do not see the necessity of formal registration.

Madagascar established a Torrens land registration system during the colonial period. Registration under the system proceeded slowly and inefficiently. Records of land once formally registered have fallen out of date because of the high costs of the formal registration process. Registration requires an average of 74 days to navigate seven different procedures, with 24 steps involved. The organisations tasked with administering the system, Services Fonciers Topographie and Domaine lack sufficient funds. Local land registry offices have been established to allow people to legalise private property rights through the issue of individual or collective land certificates. So far, only one fifth of local governments have a land registry office.

The cost of obtaining a land certificate is approximately 9.7% of the property value. The average cost MGA 60,000 ($USD350), which is more than the annual wage of many farmers. If parents die, applicants must start process again. It is costly and lengthy to determine who owns a parcel of land and all inheritors must be identified. Once a land certificate has been issued, the recipient(s) must pay taxes, which many people cannot afford. Further complicating the issue is that often people who do not have a legitimate claim to the land are the first to come forward with a claim.

Malagasy NGO Ny Tanintsika works with communities on local projects to reduce poverty and improve conservation. One of their projects works with the poorest and most marginalised people assisting them to grow food crops using sustainable methods. Beneficiaries have mostly borrowed land from family, neighbours or acquaintances, and continued access to land is insecure. Beneficiaries run the risk of other people claiming ownership of land and crops produced.

Ny Tanintsika is working to secure formal land tenure for these households, though it is proving a complex and arduous process. They are in the beginning stages of assisting communities to set up local land offices to help smallholders receive land tenure certification or title deeds (part of the Malagasy government’s National Land Tenure Reform Programme). Once a land office is set up in a commune, the community is tasked with managing the office and setting fee charges for the service. Ny Tanintsika is currently applying for funding to establish the first land office in one of the communes that they work, Ankarimbelo in the central highlands. If successful, they will expand this to other communes in their sphere of influence. If you would like to donate to this worthy cause, please visit https://www.justgiving.com/feedbacktrust/donate/

Eucalypts in Madagascar – Why?

Fuelwood, especially for the creation of charcoal, represents 92% of energy supply in Madagascar (source WWF). Estimates from the Ministry of Environment and Forests of fuelwood quantities required in Madagascar are greater than 12 million cubic meters annually. This roughly translates into 240 000 hectares of tree plantations and is the equivalent size of Masoala the largest national park in Madagascar. It is unsure whether Madagascar can meet the long-term requirements of the population with fuelwood. Dwindling supply of charcoal in some areas of Madagascar is a major threat to the remaining vestiges of native woodland and forest within these communities. Without adequate supply of fuel for cooking, reforestation projects will continue to be compromised in long-term success.

Eucalypts are fast growing, quickly supply fuelwood, are an ideal source of construction timber and provide usable timber for housing within 6-8yrs (optimum 10-18yrs species dependent). Targeted selection of suitable eucalypt species is required to improve growth rates, fuelwood supply and usable timber for construction compared to species currently used such as E. robusta. Most plantations across Madagascar exhibit very short cutting cycles (2-3yrs) that indicates more plantation wood is required to meet current fuelwood demands.

Some local native species are known that match early growth rates of eucalypts, however, native species do not sustain this level of growth over the long-term. Eucalypt species grow faster and produce more volume of wood than native species.  During the current critical period for fuelwood supply it is essential that eucalypt species are used that can meet and surpass the rate of charcoal use. The table below displays species that would be more suitable for specific climatic regions of Madagascar. Some of these are already in use but others are desperately needed in trial plantations.

Use of fast growing native species, innovation of cooking techniques and alternative energy sources will all contribute to long-term sustainable energy use in Madagascar. These initiatives will facilitate a shift away from the dependence on exotic species. However, fast growing eucalypts will meet the current demands of local, often remote, communities for fuelwood and reduce the pressure on remnant native forests.

Long-term efforts need to concentrate on a shift to incorporate native species timber plantations for construction and fuel wood supply. The time required to facilitate a shift to native sources would be reliant on a short-term need for eucalypt plantations. Native species provide multiple other benefits that exotic species do not provide.  Natural interactions with animals and other flora do not occur with exotic eucalypt trees as does with natives. The ecological-economic value of native species is much higher in the long-term than exotic eucalypt species. However, information regarding local species is not readily available although community elders, forest users and forest agents are aware of fast growing native species.

Propagation methods and planting advice for native species is also not easily available and this may be a contributing factor why widespread use of native trees has not occurred. There is much promise for the use of mycorrhiza in community nurseries which should help the growth and survival of native species. Since this technique was promoted a few years ago several groups have reported significant increases in growth and survival of native plants. VAM may be the key ingredient required to promote the use of fast growing native tree species.

Check out our post on VAM in community nurseries!

COBA nurseries for reforestation and agroforestry projects

COBA is a term used for community forest management associations (COBA’s) when forest management has been transferred to the local community. The objective of the Darwin Foundation project ‘Madagsacar: Argoforestry livelihoods project’ is to establish local nurseries within COBA’s to produce native species for reforestation / restoration and some exotic species for plantation wood and agroforestry. Ny Tanintsika works with 22 COBA’s within the Ambositra-Vondrozo forest corridor (COFAV). Ny Tanintsika has trained two nurserymen and at least one technical community agent (TAC) in each COBA. The TAC is responsible for creating a demonstration Agroforestry plot and sharing techniques learnt from Ny Tanintsika field agents with anyone in the community wishing to learn. The annual target is 20 000 seedlings produced in each COBA over 5 years.  If successful, this would produce roughly 2 million seedlings for planned revegetation activities within the corridor. The image below shows the type of landscape requiring restoration. ‘Savoka’ is the Malagasy term for abandoned agricultural land.

It is amazing to witness what Malagasy people can achieve with very limited resources. The nurseries seem very basic at first glance but produce several thousand healthy seedlings, enabling essential community reforestation projects.  Nurserymen receive very little monetary compensation, especially when considering the number of hours most of them spend in the nursery. However, they are given training by Ny Tanintsika field technicians in exchange for their services and receive the adoration of the community.  This and the opportunity to contribute to a better way of life for their families is sufficient motivation for their selfless contribution. The nurserymen are very proud of their achievements. It was fantastic being able to exchange ideas with them and assist them in their endeavours.

Seed collection of native species is done locally from the forest which helps maintain correct provenance and local genotypes for species.  Minimal seed pre-treatment is required to achieve high germination rates when viable seed has been collected. This is in stark contrast to many Australian species that exhibit many complex seed dormancy mechanisms. In Madagascar, often drying out seed prior to planting or soaking in water over night is sufficient to induce germination. Seed is sowed in germination beds or directly into poly bags depending on the species. Most seedlings are kept in the nursery for 3-6 months prior to planting in field sites.

Some native species exhibit very low survival and growth rates. This is most likely due to the absence of vital mycorrhiza associations within soil (see post on Mycrorrhiza). These mycorrhizal plant associations increase the vigour of seedlings by providing nutrients to growing plants that may otherwise be unavailable. Recently we began trials at some of the Ny Tanintsika community nurseries to produce and incorporate these essential mycorrhiza in the potting mix used in polybags for seedlings.

Visit to Mitsinjo Community Association

Association Mitsinjo is a community based environmental NGO located in Andasibe. Mitsinjo manages and protects the Analamazaotra Forest Station, Torotorofotsy wetlands and forests connected with but not part of the Andasibe-Mantadia national parks.  The organization runs ecological monitoring of endangered lemur species, with special focus on the Indri and Greater Bamboo Lemur. Mitsinjo also run several tree nurseries with an annual production capacity of more than 100,000 seedlings and comprised of approximately 120 endemic species. They are also part of an international amphibian research center created to protect the endemic frogs of Madagascar.

Find out more on their Facebook page

The restoration objectives set by Mitsinjo were developed to comply with guidelines set out in the Kyoto Protocol. The scheme encourages conservation, enhancement and restoration of natural forest corridors between larger forest fragments.  The activities attempt to encourage maximum community involvement to develop sustainable livelihoods for the local population.

We had been in contact with Mitsinjo and they invited us to visit them in Andasibe. We arrived at the reception center in the morning but a large group of tourists beat us there. They had a tour planned that morning called “Plant a Tree and Save Forests! Mitsinjo Forest Restoration Tour”. The visitors receive a presentation explaining Mitsinjo’s mission, current activities, and past successes. After the presentation the tourists went on a quick walk to view the Indri Indri followed by each planting a native tree in restoration. Fortunately after these morning commitments the head nurseryman was available to show us around after an early lunch.

At lunch we met two inspiring Malagasy men called Jean-Noel (Mitsinjo President) and Youssouf (VP and head nurserymen).  We discussed some of Mitsinjo’s recent projects and current challenges.  They had a thorough understanding of native forest restoration and firm practices in place.  We spoke about possibilities for bilateral information exchange between Ny Tanintsika and Mitsinjo. The organisations had similar projects running within the humid forests of eastern Madagascar, although separated by almost 500km.

3

In the afternoon Youssouf showed us around their very impressive nursery. We were hopeful to see some techniques that could be transferred or adapted to assist Ny Tanintsika with their projects.  We discussed a production technique for the critical ingredient in soils for restoration: Vesicular-arbuscular mycorrhiza (VAM).

See our VAM post here!

We viewed current restoration areas of the forest. We were fortunate that this area showed the different stages of restoration.  The group were restoring an area of forest that had become infested by Rubus alceifolius, a type of blackberry, and very difficult to control. Three years of slashing the blackberry was required before any native seedlings could be planted. Native species were planted with purpose and specific roles to play. Plants from all stages of succession were used in an effort to speed up the restoration process. Seedlings of species with medicinal and other benefits for the local people are planted on the boundary of the national park(s). This helped to keep the local community from entering a park to find these traditional plants and restricted the amount of disturbance within the parks.

The large areas infested by rubus and other exotic species, combined with savoka (abandoned agricultural land), makes the restoration of critical areas in Andasibe seem quite daunting. With limited financial support given to organisations like Mitsinjo, they are extremely successful and fulfill a very important role for restoration activities in Madagascar.

11